“ Great experience my first time here. It was near perfect! And I would absolutely come back and recommend. I had the tostada. It was delicious but my egg was overcooked. I asked for it over medium but the yolk was cooked all the way through. It was still tasty but would have been better, had it been cooked over medium. I might have thrown the chef off by asking for it over medium. My girlfriend go the quinoa salad, which I'm getting next time. It was so yummy. Her husband got the frittata, which he loved and my hubby got got the Chicken Milanese. Also very happy. Bottomless Bloody Marys were excellent and the Negroni got high marks. The standout was the Almond Dessert. Pure perfection. I'm also ordering that the next time. If I could give Edgewater 4.75 stars, that would really be more accurate but I only give five if it's a perfect experience. Nice ambience and great service. Overall, we were very very happy with our meal and it might be our quarterly meeting place because it's the perfect halfway point for where we live and my friends who are in East Hampton. Thank you Edgewater Restaurant. Fantastic, near perfect experience. ”

“ Great place. Wonderful view of the shinnecock bay. The appetizers were over the top and everyone in my party had a very good meal. I'd definitely recommend this place. ”

“ Edgewater was an incredible place. The view was great, the staff provided amazing service, and the food was outstanding! The lobster pasta is a must! ”

“ And four years later, this place has gotten even better! So happy they are still here and going strong! ”

“ Food was amazing! Extremely tasty! Service was extremely fast! Waiters are very friendly! Ambiance was beautiful! Looking out of the windows you can see the Shinnecock Bay Highly recommend! ”

“ Came here for a bridal shower and couldnt believe the view and food! The spaghetti and meatballs was extraordinarily delicious and they kept the amazing bread coming! I even asked for extra to take home. They did an amazing job hosting the bridal shower. I have it on my radar to go back for dinner in the near future as well. Great experience here. ”

“ Amazing food with an amazing view. I came here for my birthday dinner, and it was a surprise by the husband. Little did he know that I've been eyeing the spot for when we take drives out here. They don't take reservations but you can call 15 minutes ahead to put your name on a waitlist. We took a chance and didn't call ahead which was fine because there was only a half an hour wait, and that was on a Sunday evening. There's a nice little patio outdoor area that you could sit and wait for your name to be called for an open table. I grabbed a drink at the bar and ran it out to the patio and enjoyed the view. Only 20 minutes passed when we were called and we literally got the best seat in the house. Just outside the indoor dining area is another outdoor patio dining area that wraps around the restaurant. We were lucky enough to snag a spot that looked out to the water. From the bartender to the servers and the host everybody was really friendly and super laid-back with great recommendations. I had two different cocktails. Both were on the seasonal menu and the first one was delicious, but had a little bit too much mint that I ended up consuming , my second cocktail was just as good and both were super light and refreshing. The food was awesome, and I was surprised by a lot of the menu items that were featured. For instance, one of the appetizers was a sausage pinwheel. We ended up getting that and I was super impressed how this totally worked as an appetizer. My main course was the duck pizza, how cool of a dish is that? If you love duck, this is the pizza for you! It had mushrooms...it had shredded, delicious and very well cooked duck ... and on top was a plum sauce that was drizzled very generously and paired well with all the toppings on the pizza. This was an awesome way to close out my birthday weekend. I can't wait to try the spot again. We're definitely putting it on our list of go to restaurants when driving out east. ”